Lake Martin Home Prices Per Square Foot - Lake Martin Voice - Lake Martin Real Estate - Waterfront Homes, Lots, Property For Sale

Lake Martin Home Prices Per Square Foot

Wild and Scenic Film Festival Tour in Alabama
January 25, 2021
Where is Chimney Rock on Lake Martin?
February 23, 2021

What does a Lake Martin waterfront home cost per square foot?

As a full time real estate agent here on the lake, I hear this question from time to time. While (as a numbers guy) I would love to have a super specific answer, I am afraid that I cannot. In fact, I think this is the entirely wrong question to be asking. I think per square foot analysis is the single most misleading statistic in all of Lake Martin real estate.

Why do I say that? Well, here at Lake Martin, a waterfront home’s overall value is determined, to a great degree, by the value of the lot. It’s not just A factor – it is THE factor. The view, privacy, and location of a waterfront property is what drives value. None of these attributes show up in a home’s square footage. A small home with a great view sells for much higher than a large home with an inferior one.

Please consider these two recent examples. These two waterfront homes sold within 3 months of each other, about one mile away from each other, and during a raging sellers’ market.

Example A is a 900 square feet list price $499,000, or about $554 per square foot.

Example B is a 4,100 square feet home with a list price $499,000 or about $122 per square foot.

Which is the better deal?  If you rely on the price per square foot method, you simply don’t have enough data.

When Example A sold, it sold for a sales price of $505,000, or about $561 per square foot. Yes, it sold for over list price, so that means $554 per square foot was actually too low, according to the market.

Conversely, Example B had a sales price $435,000, or about $106 per square foot. Had the buyer only relied on that, they would have overpaid by $59,000.

What was the big differences in the two homes? View, for one thing. Example A was a smaller home but it sat on a lot with a big water view. That’s why everyone is here at Lake Martin. I have been selling homes here for many years and no one has ever told me, “give me the worst view on the lake.” Everyone wants as good a view as their budget may allow.

Another difference was that Example B was almost too big. It had oversized rooms. A ton of area, but not very useable. That simply is not prioritized at Lake Martin.

Do you own waterfront property on Lake Martin and need help pricing it? I would love to help, at no cost or obligation to you. I can give you a “Ballpark Price” if you would like – click here.

Are you thinking about buying here at Lake Martin? I can help with that, too. I would be glad to show you the valuation method that appraisers and I prefer- the sales comparison method.

Please contact me here or call or text me at the number at the top of the screen.

I am John Coley and I would love to help!